Survey results!

This morning I ran a quick survey to see what Fulham fans thought of the squad.  It’s not meant to provide any great insight into the world, but I did think it would be interesting to see how players are perceived, and the extent to which these views are held.  We got 100 responses (the most allowed by the survey system without having to pay) and the results are as follows.  The first question takes the Football Manager squad designations for simplicity.

What, if anything, does this tell us?

That we’re quite well set as a squad.  Hangeland, Zamora, Dempsey, Hughes and Murphy are seen as the squad’s Key Players (in that order), with an impressive group of Schwarzer (who’d be more ‘key’ if Stockdale wasn’t around, I’m sure), Dembele, Sidwell, Baird and Duff all seen as First Team regulars.

That’s pretty strong. There are notable gaps, though: we only have one centre-forward clearly of first team standard, and full-back is iffy (we knew this without having to do a survey, of course, but the data underlines the fact quite nicely).

If we look how results have gone, another way might be:

Untouchables (undisputed key players): Hangeland and Zamora
Key first team players (either key or first team): Dempsey, Hughes, Murphy, Schwarzer, Dembele
Good regulars (mainly first team and some rotation): Sidwell, Baird, Duff, Davies, Etuhu
Squad player (others expected to contribute): Johnson, Senderos, Gera, Greening, Salcido, (Stockdale)

It’s quite a nice little breakdown of where we are as a squad.

Other thoughts:

Hangeland and Zamora are miles ahead of everyone else;
Salcido (and his uncertain status) divides opinion (who knew?);
Greening’s late run has persuaded people he’s worth his squad place;
A decent number of people think Senderos is going to step up into the first team;
Sidwell has grown on people fast; he’s the clear winner over Etuhu in midfield, and many already see him as a key player.

In a secondary poll I wanted to find out what to do with Dembele and Dempsey.

The poll doesn’t really help.  Both would ideally be playing off the centre-forward.  Dempsey is a decent bet for the left-flank, but people really don’t want to see him at centre-forward (surprised so low – I think he’s okay there).

Finally, I asked where people thought Fulham would finish next year.  The answer: 8th.

4 thoughts on “Survey results!

  1. The Dembele/ Dempsey conondrum interests me the most. Given Jols past i wouldnt be surprised to see a 4-3-2-1 formation next season that utilises Dempsey and Dembele just behind Zamora but also given them the opportunity to drift wide. I think they are both players that are better when allowed to roam as defenders find them hard to pick up.

    That would also allow us to play Murphy, Sidwell and Etuhu in midfield. Let the latter 2 do all the running and leave Danny free to do what he does best and get the ball into our forwards in dangerous positions. Of course these could all change given a few signings but its something I’d like to see us try.

  2. Brilliant stuff which pretty much conforms to how I see the squad.

    We also don’t seem to be that far away from how Mark Hughes utilised the team. It will be interesting to see what Jol makes of the squad and any differences in style or formation that may marginalise current first teamers or allow some a chance to shine.

    By the way – nice new design!

  3. In our current formation, I’d want a proper striker to partner Bob with Dempsey on the left and Dembele on the right. Of course, that would mean signing a striker. I’d start the season with Duff and Dembele platooning until we sort what Duff’s going to be able to give us. Lets not forget, he is coming off another injury. This would also give Dembele a little time to get comfortable in that role.

    While I like Matt’s idea at first glance, Dembele’s goal scoring record with have to improve dramatically for that to work.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s