A thought or two about Fulham’s transfer policy

It occurs to me that the chairman’s spending has come in bursts, and when Premiership survival was under threat.

http://www.transferleague.co.uk/premiership-transfers/fulham-transfers.html (for full details)

Big splurges (Premier League era):

On promotion to the division
When Chris Coleman’s team nearly stumbled out of the division and Lawrie Sanchez was given money to overhaul things
When this didn’t work, Roy Hodgson got money to overhaul things

Since then we’ve been in tick-over mode. A little here and there, but since Hodgson’s first summer we’ve really not spent much, Damien Duff being the single big commitment (fee plus wages), players like Sidwell and Dembele probably not far off. Mark Schwarzer came on a free but will have been paid good money. John-Arne Riise has seen the big time and will not be here on the minimum wage. Equally, I’m sure that in this time the squad, having proven itself, has not gone without the odd pay-rise and extension, but running down that list it’s noticeable that we really haven’t bought a big name for an eternity.  The star-player-down-on-his-luck approach has worked extremely well.  If we look at our current first team and their reputation when we signed them:

Schwarzer – good goalkeeper who could have been at a bigger club than Middlesbrough. Mike Kelly played a part in his decision to come here.
Hughes – goodish defender struggling to escape from the journeyman ranks.
Hangeland – good player from Scandinavia so not known. Prior relationship with Hodgson helped.
Senderos – good player at Arsenal but had struggled with injuries and deemed surplus to requirements.
Riise – good player in his day, still playing at the top level with Roma.
Dempsey – up and coming player from the US, previously wanted by Everton and Charlton but very much a gamble by Coleman.
Murphy – struggled at Spurs (death of his father hadn’t helped), hadn’t set the world on fire at Charlton. Reputation nothing like it is now.
Etuhu – reserve player at Sunderland.
(Sidwell – good player, good enough that Chelsea signed him from Reading. Then couldn’t get into the Villa team).
Duff – five years removed from being a key player in Mourinho’s wonder team, found himself playing left-back in an awful Newcastle side.
Zamora – decent player who hadn’t really pushed on. Not much was expected.
Johnson – living a bit off reputation even then, AJ had been fantastic at Palace but David Moyes had started to play him wide on the right.

A funny old lot when you go through them one by one. There’s no real pattern there besides not buying at the top of the market.  We don’t have a reputation for paying well but I suspect that this is slightly misleading, as most of the above are now established Premier League players with strong reputations and will surely be remunerated accordingly.

So given the stability of the above side, the only thing is to get younger.  This Jol has done, relatively cheaply, and now an ageing squad has players around the edges to phase in.  But reading this, thinking about this, it seems much more likely that we’ll see a few more bit part players to make up the numbers and maybe turn into something, because it’s not a squad that’s obviously crying out for investment *if you consider past spending sprees*.

8 thoughts on “A thought or two about Fulham’s transfer policy

  1. “But reading this, thinking about this, it seems much more likely that we’ll see a few more bit part players to make up the numbers and maybe turn into something, because it’s not a squad that’s obviously crying out for investment *if you consider past spending sprees*.”

    I agree that this is what we’re likely to see, and I think it makes the most sense. It’s very much why I had hoped the Cameron Jerome deal would go through. He seems a player very much like Zamora was before he came here — solid reputation at best — is young, and likely willing to play understudy. We’re never going to compete for the big-name up and coming players, nor, of course, the big-name established players, so we have to invest in young-ish players, not exactly excelling, but with the ability to make it with the right coaching. We then have to have faith in our coaching set-up to actually make them better players.

    Having said all that, it’s still going to cost us some money: 5m for a striker, 3m for a winger, and 2m for a right back, still adds up to 10m. Add in what we paid for Gecov, Kasami and Riise (couldn’t be less than 6m all in I don’t reckon), and that’s an outlay of 16m for the senior squad. In addition, there appears to have been a continuation of the policy of steady recruitment of youth-teamers, maybe costing as much as 2m. Add that all up and you’re talking a conservative estimate of a total summer outlay of 18m at a time when there effectively hasn’t been player sales. I’d say that’s a pretty big investment, despite getting no big-name players in.

    1. yes and we haven’t spent that since Sanchez when we were awful. So I wouldn’t be surprised if we don’t end up with fanny adams from here… Cameron Jerome, a loan of someone like Alan Hutton, and three young players on a punt.

      1. To me that doesn’t sound terrible at all. A back-up for Zamora should be the number 1 priority. After that — and assuming that a miracle happens and Jol realizes that Baird is actually rather good at right-back — the squad is pretty decent.

  2. dare I say that maybe Jol will need to sell to generate the funds he needs? Could this be the time to cash in on Zamora and bring in another 29 year old Zamoraesque player? Carlton Cole? I wouldn’t put this comment on the other message boards as it would bring a whole lot of abuse..

    1. We have let a lot of people go and have two bona-fide strikers in the squad.

      I doubt that we will have to sell any players to buy, otherwise we would be endangering our premier league status.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s