Rich may have some quality observations in the morning, but I just wanted to rip apart something I read about the match.

The lede in the Guardian’s (awful) recap:

André Villas-Boas’s selection may suggest the Carling Cup is of minor importance but after his 10-man team won this entertaining tie on the penalty shoot-out, courtesy of Bryan Ruiz’s missed fifth kick that smacked the crossbar and bounced close to the goalline, he will be content.

Right, a starting XI featuring Kalou, Alex, Cech, Sturridge and Luiz–all proven players–coupled with a bench consisting of Turnbull, Terry, Bosingwa, Lampard, Mikel, Didier Drogba, Mata really shows this competition was of minor importance.

Especially when compared to a Fulham lineup where about 75% of the team were handed debuts or had under 5 first team appearances each. And whose only regular starter was their goalie. And a bench whose combined cost equals maybe that of Mata’s deal alone.

In a match that gradually caught fire Villa-Boas’s team dominated as it moved into extra-time, but continued their frustrating dance of normal play when chances could not be finished.

Um, pretty certain it was end-to-end and no one team dominated until Alex got sent off. Oh, okay, if you consider “dominated” meaning playing 9 proven internationals behind the ball and hoping to score on the counter, fine; Chelsea sure whipped our asses!

From the side that were beaten 3-1 at Manchester United on Sunday, the Portuguese had retained only Cech and Sturridge. Oriol Romeu, Romelu Lukaku and Ryan Bertrand were handed full debuts,

Again, as compared to three Fulham players that were handed their debuts, two others that saw just their second starts ever, and another that has played as many first XI minutes domestically as the entire match saw. Plus a bench consisting of two players that have never, played for the club, and another who’s just recently returned from the witness protection program.

I could go on, but as Project Pat once sang, Good Googly Moogly.

7 thoughts on “Recaps

  1. Absurd stuff from the Guardian. Nice critique Timmy. So, is it just me, or was Frei an absolute revelation, tirelessly running the flank, taking on defenders one on one, distributing well and even earning a PK? Also, I though Ruiz showed a lot of quality. He tired as the game wore on but he had some absolutely brilliant touches. And finally, not Senderos but the other guy, the new centerback: he was class, no?

  2. Excellent recap. It’s a shame no one seems to be interested in how very good our b team really is. I wouldn’t mind seeing this line up again soon. Maybe it’s closer to what Jol has in mind for tactics. The speed what exhilarating.

  3. I seem to remember that 7 people from the “weakened Liverpool squad” that we beat 1-0 several years ago, started in their next game — The European Champions League final. But, as John Ford was wont to say, “When legend interferes with fact, print the legend.”

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s